With the recent announcement that HSQ Investments, Kingswood's private equity backer, has agreed to take control of the company, the spotlight has turned once again to the fraught landscape of adviser consolidators, particularly those reliant on private equity funding. This takeover underscores heightened concerns regarding the sustainability of aggressive acquisition strategies in the wealth management sector.

Since HSQ first backed Kingswood in 2019 with an investment of up to £80 million aimed at establishing it as a leading UK advice-led wealth consolidator, the firm has undertaken substantial growth, managing to make 19 acquisitions and considerably increase its assets from £2.5 billion to £12.9 billion by mid-2024. Concurrently, Kingswood's revenues surged from £10.1 million to £86.2 million as it positioned itself for a robust future. However, this strategy came at a steep price, with Kingswood accruing a staggering £91.6 million in debt, leading HSQ to extend an additional £25.8 million in loans to cover rising operational costs.

Giles Dunning, a partner at Stephens Scown, emphasises the complexities of managing fast-paced acquisitions, warning of the dangers inherent in high leverage and the necessity of careful integration. “PE-backed acquirers tend to be highly leveraged and thinly capitalised on the balance sheet,” he stated. The risk extends beyond mere financials; Dunning highlighted that integration challenges often go underestimated, urging firms to prepare adequately to handle the resource-intensive nature of mergers and acquisitions.

HSQ's plan post-takeover includes merging Kingswood's UK and Ireland operations with another firm within its portfolio, signalling a strategic reflection on the scalability of such ambitious consolidation efforts. The trend of private equity firms entering the financial advisory market gained significant momentum after the 2012 Retail Distribution Review, but as the regulatory environment has tightened—most notably with the Financial Conduct Authority's increased scrutiny under its consumer duty initiative—the landscape has become more complex. Not only are compliance costs rising, but the expectations around governance must now translate into demonstrable value for clients. “A robust governance and compliance track record has shifted from being a tick-box exercise to becoming a genuine driver of value,” according to Callum Pirie, a senior vice-president at Houlihan Lokey.

As interest rates rise, the methods of financing deals are adapting as well. Jonathan Greenstein of Lagom Consulting has observed a growing trend towards secondary buyouts and recapitalisation as the IPO market remains subdued. Similarly, Emma Napier from NextWealth remarks on the evolving nature of private equity involvement, pointing out that firms are increasingly aware of the pitfalls associated with rapid growth and are adopting a more measured, intensive due diligence process.

The ongoing review by the FCA into adviser market consolidation reflects a broader apprehension regarding the potential decline in advice quality amid rapid growth. Greenstein articulated concerns over weak oversight and potential conflicts of interest, noting a push from private equity firms to enhance compliance teams and governance structures. Yet, many smaller consolidators face challenges keeping pace with these heightened expectations, risking their ability to serve clients effectively.

Dunning explains that contemporary M&A strategies are now built around client outcomes, stressing that “commercial incentives are still key but they have to be secondary to the interests of the client.” To address the demands for compliance and oversight, many firms are looking at hybrid integration approaches, balancing the need for centralised operations while retaining local branding and adviser autonomy—a necessary compromise to maintain trust and continuity with clients.

Despite the apparent surge of interest from private equity firms in the financial sector, the sustainability of this model remains uncertain, especially as regulatory pressures mount and compliance costs escalate. Louise Jeffreys, managing director of Gunner & Co, warns that deals made before the recent surge in interest rates are now considered expensive, reflecting a broader trend of rising valuations and heightened scrutiny around the financial viability of acquisitions.

As Kingswood's situation exemplifies, the path forward for private equity-backed consolidators involves recognising the importance of integrating compliance, managing debt effectively, and ultimately acting in the best interest of clients. The industry's evolution into a landscape where quality must be prioritised over mere scale will determine the success of such investments in the long run. The operational hurdles of managing a growing portfolio coupled with regulatory expectations pose significant challenges that could reshape the very fabric of the financial advisory profession in the UK.

Reference Map

  1. Paragraph 1-2
  2. Paragraph 3
  3. Paragraph 3
  4. Paragraph 4
  5. Paragraph 5
  6. Paragraph 6
  7. Paragraph 7
  8. Paragraph 8
  9. Paragraph 9
  10. Paragraph 10
  11. Paragraph 11
  12. Paragraph 12
  13. Paragraph 13
  14. Paragraph 14
  15. Paragraph 15
  16. Paragraph 16

Source: Noah Wire Services