Christian Allard, co-leader of Aberdeen City Council, recently reflected on the closure of Resident X, a street food venue that once promised to rejuvenate the heart of the city. After investing over £1.3 million in the venture, which opened in December 2022 within the council’s Marischal Square, Allard admitted that the ambition behind the project may have been misplaced. Initially presented as an "Instagrammers playground," the venue faced numerous challenges, which culminated in its closing down less than a year later.

The 10,000 sq ft market quickly encountered significant financial turbulence. Following a tumultuous operational history that involved two changes in management, it ultimately ended when its latest operators returned the keys to the council. They cited unviable financial conditions and declining footfall as the principal reasons for their departure. Notably, low attendance persisted despite attempts to ignite interest through events like DJ nights and pop-up festivities, hinting at deeper systemic issues within Aberdeen's market for such venues.

Allard's admissions shed light on the miscalculations in its conception. He acknowledged that perhaps Marischal Square’s specific positioning, while adjacent to tourist attractors like Marischal College, did not lend itself to sustainable crowd engagement. “Maybe, the Marischal Square location was too ambitious… maybe, it could have been done with a bigger public space and a smaller building,” he remarked. This introspection is crucial, especially as the council prepares to launch Flint, a new food and drink market on The Green, anticipated to harness the lessons learned from Resident X's fallout.

Critics of the Flint project have expressed concerns that it may repeat the pitfalls of its predecessor. Opposition leaders are wary of the similarity in ambition and the inherent risks associated with high financial investment in a potentially saturated market. However, Allard remains optimistic that Flint can carve a unique niche by focusing on local produce and offering a more spacious environment designed to foster community interaction. Scheduled to feature 11 vendors and an expansive events area, Flint promises a diverse culinary experience intended to distinguish it from the troubled legacy of Resident X.

Emphasising the need for public space in the city centre, Allard envisions that Flint will not solely serve commercial interests but also enhance the urban landscape. “The city centre should not be about buildings; it should be about space,” he stated, underscoring the potential of the new market to serve as a vibrant community hub rather than merely another commercial venture.

As Flint's construction progresses, its success will hinge not only on the distinctive offerings it presents but also on its ability to attract and maintain foot traffic in an area that has proven challenging for similar operations. Learning from its predecessor's missteps, the city council appears poised to navigate the complexities of urban development with caution and a renewed focus on integrating community needs into its vision for the future.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services