Legendary referee Nigel Owens has weighed in on a contentious schoolboy try that has sparked considerable debate online. The incident occurred during a match between Marlborough Boys’ College and Nelson College in New Zealand, where a penalty taken by Marlborough centre Anru Erasmus resulted in an innovative yet controversial scoring method. Instead of a conventional kick at the posts, Erasmus opted to chip the ball towards the left corner of the field, enabling his teammate Finn Neal to score an uncontested try. The refereeing team awarded the try, believing that the play conformed to the rules.

However, Owens, who boasts significant experience officiating at the highest levels of rugby, including the 2015 Rugby World Cup final, has publicly countered the decision on social media. He argued that the try should not have been awarded, noting the absence of a genuine attempt to kick at goal as stipulated by World Rugby’s regulations. Specifically, under Law 8.20, a team must indicate their intention to kick at goal and then perform a proper kick; failing to do so nullifies any subsequent scoring from that play. Owens asserted that in this case, the penalty should have been annulled, and a scrum awarded instead.

The rules governing such scenarios are crucial to understanding how the game is meant to operate. According to World Rugby, the intention to take a kick must be clearly communicated—this can be signalled through various means including the arrival of the kicking tee or sand, or when a player marks the ground. This stipulation not only upholds the integrity of the game but ensures that all teams compete on a level playing field.

Under recent changes approved by World Rugby, the emphasis has been placed on enforcing existing laws to facilitate smoother gameplay. A series of directives taking effect from January 2023 aim to reduce time-wasting and speed up the game. These include a shot clock that mandates that kickers take their penalty shots within 60 seconds of indicating their intent. Such measures are designed to enhance the spectator experience, particularly in the lead-up to the 2023 Rugby World Cup, and signify a shift towards a more dynamic format.

With the introduction of these law amendments, there is a clear push for a more fluid game, with the governing body already working towards future changes. A new set of rule adjustments due in July 2024 will further fine-tune aspects of play, including offside laws following kicks and measures to prevent certain negative player actions. This progressive approach reflects the evolving nature of rugby, aiming to attract a broader, younger fanbase while maintaining the sport’s storied traditions.

The discussion surrounding this particular try underscores the importance of clarity and adherence to the rules, which serve as the backbone of both grassroots and professional rugby. As the sport continues to grow, engaging with its laws and regulations becomes ever more critical in ensuring fair play and enhancing the overall enjoyment for players and fans alike.

Source: Noah Wire Services