Jordan Gray’s return to the Edinburgh Fringe with her latest show, Is That a Cck in Your Pocket, or Are You Just Here to Kill Me?, comes on the heels of significant acclaim and controversy. Following her celebrated debut, Is It a Bird?*, which marked her as the first transgender performer to headline the London Palladium, Gray has firmly established herself as a bold voice in comedy. However, the journey has not been without its challenges. Her audacious antics, including a starkly naked appearance that triggered a wave of transphobic backlash, have underscored not only her talent but the societal tensions surrounding her identity.

The new show, while described as having moments of brilliance, reflects an unavoidable struggle with the so-called “difficult second show syndrome.” Despite this, Gray engages the audience with her characteristic flair, employing both song and stand-up to address her experience as a transgender woman navigating a complex social landscape. The show opens with unapologetic humour, diving into themes of self-identity, fame, and the absurdity often surrounding gender discussions. In particular, her lyrics reveal a fearless approach; one song provocatively declares an intention to "fuck myself with my own dismembered shlong," a testament to her commitment to combining explicit humour with personal narrative.

Critics have noted that while Is That a Cck in Your Pocket* may not achieve the same heights as its predecessor, it offers a compelling mix of sharp observations and comedic experimentation. Although some of her content—such as a skit on her wife's malapropisms—has drawn criticism for being uneven, the performance culminates in a moving finale that poignantly reflects the difficulties faced by transgender individuals in 2025. Yet, the fluctuating tone throughout the show leaves some questioning the sincerity of her final message, contrasting her earlier comedic bravado with genuine emotional weight.

Gray’s ability to oscillate between brilliant entertainment and provocative commentary aligns her with the likes of Russell Brand and Tim Minchin, whose bold styles and musical comedy resonate with her own. Reviews have pointed out that her performance extends beyond mere jokes, incorporating satire that challenges societal norms—most notably in her exploration of transphobia and identity issues. While jokes about controversial figures, such as Donald Trump, are made in jest, they raise eyebrows and provoke thought about acceptance and societal double standards in gender dynamics.

Ultimately, despite the challenges and mixed critical reception, Gray's sophomore effort serves to keep her in the spotlight, propelling her comedic career onward. Her knack for intertwining humour with pressing societal issues ensures she remains a significant voice in contemporary comedy, navigating the personal, societal, and comedic with an unapologetic zeal. As she continues to blend edgy humour and insightful commentary, audiences can expect her to remain a formidable force on the comedy circuit.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services