In Hunia Chawla’s poignant play Permission, the quest for liberation serves as a central theme, stirring deeper exploration of the internal and external conflicts faced by women. Set against the contrasting backdrops of Karachi and London, the narrative follows Hanna, a young Pakistani woman portrayed with intensity by Anisa Butt. As she embarks on her journey seeking independence, the audience witnesses her grappling with the weight of patriarchal constraints that govern her life in Karachi, where basic freedoms, such as walking the streets alone or dating, are fraught with danger.
Life in London, however, presents its own challenges, complicating Hanna’s pursuit of autonomy. Here, she encounters Anushe, a forthright third-year student played compellingly by Rea Malhotra Mukhtyar, who encourages her to engage in activism against the university’s ties to arms dealers. This undertaking carries greater risk for Hanna, who is navigating the complexities of immigrant life on a visa. The play illuminates how various systems of control manifest differently across cultures, creating a nuanced juxtaposition between Hanna’s experiences in Karachi and London.
Beyond the broader socio-political themes, Permission presents a touching platonic love story. While Hanna flirts with independence by moving abroad, her loyal friend Minza, also played by Mukhtyar, remains in Karachi, passionately engaging in the Aurat Marches against gender-based injustices. Their friendship transcends physical distance, maintained through phone calls that oscillate between typical teenage worries and profound discussions regarding women's rights. Directed by Neetu Singh, these intimate exchanges form the emotional core of the narrative. However, they also highlight the play’s inherent tension, demonstrating how the disparity between personal friendship and societal constraints influences their bond.
While Permission features moments of brilliance, it grapples with creative inconsistencies that detract from its overall impact. The initial setup, where Butt’s Hanna delivers a monologue that establishes the play's focus on female experiences, eventually gives way to male voices projected through speakers, creating a disjointed narrative flow. Audience interaction, introduced towards the play's conclusion, feels somewhat forced rather than organic. Furthermore, certain character choices, such as a scene where Hanna is caught smoking by her father that lacks significant consequences, may leave viewers seeking a deeper exploration of the implications of rebellion within the framework of familial expectations.
Despite its flaws, Permission embodies the beginnings of a compelling exploration of identity, freedom, and the various expectations imposed on women. Chawla’s ability to weave personal stories within broader cultural contexts invites the audience to reflect on their own notions of liberty and the struggles that accompany the pursuit of autonomy in different corners of the world.
In reflecting upon the play’s development, Chawla herself has shared insights about its inspiration, drawing from the real-life struggles of women she encountered growing up in Pakistan. The narrative is not merely a tale of migration but a deeper commentary on friendship, agency, and the contestation of cultural norms. As this vibrant piece continues to evolve, it stands as a testament to the complex tapestry of women's lives, bridging cultural divides while illuminating the universal battle for liberation.
📌 Reference Map:
Source: Noah Wire Services