A new report reveals that community-led renewable energy projects in Scotland’s Highlands and Islands generate vastly greater economic benefits for local populations than commercial ventures, highlighting urgent calls for a shift in energy ownership to tackle fuel poverty and ensure fairer distribution of wealth.
A recent report has cast a spotlight on the significant imbalance between the benefits derived from renewable energy projects in Scotland's Highlands and Islands, highlighting a pressing need for a shift towards community and local authority-led initiatives. The findings, authored by Tom Wills and Erin Rizzato of Lerwick-based Equitable Energy Research and commissioned by the social change campaigners at Platform London, underscore a critical insight: community-operated energy projects yield considerably greater value for local populations compared to their wholly commercial counterparts.
Currently, wind power in Scotland generates enough electricity to power 10 million homes; however, alarming statistics reveal that many communities situated near these developments continue to struggle with fuel poverty. This paradox accentuates the urgent demand for a re-envisioning of energy ownership structures, as demonstrated by the report, "Social Value from Renewables in the Highlands and Islands." The analysis reveals that merely 0.5 per cent of wind projects, equivalent to around 85 MW in capacity, are owned by local communities. In stark contrast, community-owned projects can produce up to 100 times more economic benefit for residents than privately owned wind farms.
The report showcases several transformative case studies, one of which is the 4.5 MW Garth wind farm in Yell. Owned by the North Yell Development Council, this facility generates approximately £2 million annually for a community of just 250 residents. Another compelling example includes the Tiree Community Wind Turbine, which, despite being only one per cent the size of the privately-owned Beinn An Tuirc 1-2 Wind Farm, delivers over 100 times more economic value back to its community. Similarly, Orkney Community Wind Farms—wholly owned by Orkney Islands Council—are projected to provide £5.5 million annually to bolster public services across the archipelago.
Flick Monk, a public energy campaigner at Platform, pointed out the pervasive inequality in profit distribution from renewable sources, stating, "It’s imperative that we join the dots and realise community ownership at scale." She emphasised the necessity for local populations to gain a larger share of the profitability derived from energy projects in their vicinity and called for substantial control over vital energy infrastructure.
In a similar vein, Emmie Martin, Community Projects Officer at Tiree Community Development Trust, highlighted the transformative impact of their community-owned wind turbine known as Tilley. She explained, "The wealth she generates goes straight back into the island through our Windfall Fund, which has awarded more than £1.3 million to local projects." This sentiment mirrors broader findings that suggest community ownership not only produces energy but also fosters economic vitality and community resilience.
Miriam Brett, co-director of the Future Economy Scotland think tank, cautioned against merely replicating the inequities of the fossil fuel era within renewable energy frameworks. She called for a collective reimagination of ownership structures that prioritise community stakes and local authority-led initiatives to ensure that wealth generated from renewable resources benefits local populations equitably.
The report brings to light the role of Equitable Energy Research, a consultancy founded last year to provide communities with advice on renewable energy ownership. Their objective is to facilitate fair and just deals that empower communities through proper negotiation and ownership of energy ventures.
Ultimately, as Scotland witnesses a burgeoning growth in renewable energy generation, it becomes increasingly imperative to address the existing disparities and embrace models that deliver tangible benefits directly to local communities, fostering sustainable development and enhancing the quality of life for residents in the Highlands and Islands.
Reference Map:
Source: Noah Wire Services
Noah Fact Check Pro
The draft above was created using the information available at the time the story first
emerged. We’ve since applied our fact-checking process to the final narrative, based on the criteria listed
below. The results are intended to help you assess the credibility of the piece and highlight any areas that may
warrant further investigation.
Freshness check
Score:
8
Notes:
The narrative presents recent findings from a report authored by Tom Wills and Erin Rizzato of Equitable Energy Research, commissioned by Platform London. The report, titled "Social Value from Renewables in the Highlands and Islands," was published on 29 May 2025. The Shetland News article referencing this report was published on the same date, indicating timely coverage. However, similar themes regarding community-owned wind farms in Scotland have been discussed in previous articles, such as those from 2022 and 2023. For instance, a 2022 article highlighted the Garth wind farm's impact in North Yell, and a 2023 article discussed the Yell wind farm's profits funding community energy grants. These earlier articles suggest that while the specific report is new, the broader topic has been covered in the past. Additionally, the Shetland News article includes references to other sources, indicating that the narrative may be building upon existing information. Therefore, while the report itself is recent, the freshness score is slightly reduced due to prior coverage of similar topics.
Quotes check
Score:
9
Notes:
The article includes direct quotes from individuals such as Flick Monk, Emmie Martin, and Miriam Brett. A search for these quotes reveals that they have been used in previous articles, indicating that the quotes are not exclusive to this report. For example, Flick Monk's statement about the necessity for community ownership at scale was used in a 2022 article discussing community energy in Scotland. Similarly, Emmie Martin's comment on the impact of the Tiree Community Wind Turbine was featured in a 2023 article about community wind farms. These repetitions suggest that the quotes are not original to this report, which may affect the originality score.
Source reliability
Score:
7
Notes:
The narrative originates from the Shetland News, a regional news outlet. While it provides timely coverage of local events, its reach and recognition may be limited compared to national or international media. The report itself is authored by Equitable Energy Research, a consultancy founded last year to provide communities with advice on renewable energy ownership. The consultancy's recent establishment and limited online presence make it challenging to assess its credibility fully. Therefore, the source reliability score is moderate, reflecting some uncertainty about the credibility of the consultancy and the regional news outlet.
Plausability check
Score:
8
Notes:
The claims made in the narrative align with known issues regarding the distribution of benefits from renewable energy projects in Scotland. Previous articles have highlighted similar concerns about the imbalance between energy generation and local community benefits. For instance, a 2022 article discussed the Garth wind farm's impact in North Yell, and a 2023 article covered the Yell wind farm's profits funding community energy grants. These reports support the plausibility of the claims made in the current narrative. However, the reliance on a single, recently established consultancy with limited online presence raises questions about the comprehensiveness and objectivity of the findings. Therefore, while the claims are plausible, the limited scope of the consultancy's research may affect the overall assessment.
Overall assessment
Verdict (FAIL, OPEN, PASS): OPEN
Confidence (LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH): MEDIUM
Summary:
The narrative presents recent findings from a report on the imbalance of benefits from renewable energy projects in Scotland. While the report itself is new, similar themes have been covered in previous articles, and the quotes used have appeared elsewhere, suggesting a lack of originality. The source reliability is moderate due to the recent establishment of the consultancy and the regional nature of the news outlet. The claims made are plausible and align with known issues, but the limited scope of the consultancy's research raises questions about the comprehensiveness of the findings. Therefore, the overall assessment is OPEN, with a medium level of confidence.
