An Italian cruise line has faced significant backlash following an incident involving the Costa Favolosa, where nearly 3,000 passengers were allowed to disembark in Lerwick, Shetland, despite reports of gastrointestinal illness on board. Passengers had been sailing on a seven-day cruise from Hamburg when symptoms began to emerge. On 20 May, shortly before the ship docked, both NHS Shetland and the Lerwick Port Authority expressed concern over not having been informed of any health issues prior to the arrival of the vessel.

Dr Susan Laidlaw, director of Public Health at NHS Shetland, remarked that the health body was only alerted to the situation late in the afternoon of the same day. “However, we now understand that a small number of passengers with symptoms of gastroenteritis were being appropriately managed by the medical team on-board the vessel,” she stated. The implication that effective measures were in place on the ship raises questions about the timely communication between cruise operators and health authorities, particularly given that a mandatory health declaration should have been made prior to the ship's arrival.

Local businesses quick to react included R. Robertson and Son, a bus company that cancelled tours after witnessing one passenger visibly sick. Managing Director Sonia Robertson highlighted the potential economic impact, noting, “Something like this could have crippled the whole company and affect a lot of our staff and services.” Meanwhile, Celia Smith, owner of Blyde Welcome coffee shop, shared that local businesses felt unprepared for the situation, stating, “We could’ve been better prepared; we could’ve had more sanitiser and some businesses had face masks.”

This incident isn’t isolated; cruises have historically been venues for gastrointestinal illness outbreaks. In May 2024, P&O Cruises’ Ventura experienced a significant norovirus outbreak, affecting over 500 individuals. Similarly, earlier reports have chronicled several outbreaks aboard vessels, emphasizing the challenges of managing health on ships, particularly amid crowded conditions. The Fred Olsen cruise ship, The Black Watch, had experienced multiple outbreaks, illustrating the persistent vulnerabilities associated with large-scale maritime travel. In one such case, authorities highlighted that preventing cross-contamination during passenger embarkations and disembarkations posed a particular challenge, especially in terminals without adequate segregation.

Following the Lerwick incident, Costa Cruises asserted that it obtained the necessary clearance to dock. They claimed that upon receiving reports of mild gastrointestinal symptoms, enhanced disinfection and sanitation measures were swiftly enacted. However, the overall effectiveness and speed of response to such health concerns are crucial. Dr Laidlaw recommended hand washing and the use of bleach-based cleaning products to mitigate the spread of infection.

In light of this event and similar outbreaks, authorities like Lerwick Port Authority are reassessing their protocols. The Authority indicated that parties involved in such situations would undergo measures to tighten documentation and health declaration procedures before ports of call, aiming to ensure that health issues are disclosed timely in the future. The repercussions of such outbreaks extend beyond immediate health concerns, impacting local economies and the broader cruise industry, which relies heavily on passenger volumes for economic vitality.

As public health and cruise lines navigate the complexities of managing outbreaks, the overarching reliance on effective communication and stringent health protocols remains paramount. With cruise tourism experiencing a resurgence, lessons learnt from incidents such as this are critical for safeguarding both passenger health and local communities.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services