In a move to champion local ownership, the North Queensferry Trust has launched an appeal following the Scottish Government's rejection of their bid to buy the historic Albert Hotel—a cornerstone of the community. The decision, which came under the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016, has sparked outcry, as the community aims to preserve the hotel not just as a business venture but as a vital social hub for the village.

Melanie Ward MP has taken a vocal stance against the Scottish Ministers' decision, describing it as “short-sighted and deeply disappointing.” Speaking at Westminster, she highlighted the community's resolve to restore the hotel for public use and asserted that community ownership is “incredibly valuable.” Ward's comments resonate with the sentiments of local residents who see the hotel not merely as a building, but as an integral part of their identity and culture.

The Albert Hotel dates back to 1824 and has been closed since 2017, a prolonged absence that has left the village without its only pub. Local councillor David Barratt confirmed that the Scottish Government's decision was influenced by doubts regarding the sustainability of the community's business case. The rejection was compounded by a failed application for the hotel to be converted into flats, a proposition that faced fierce local opposition, with 133 letters of objection filed. The community's fears seemed to echo a broader concern: that conversion would result in a loss of a vital community asset.

In response to the planning debacle, villagers formed The Albert Community Group Ltd, a not-for-profit company aimed at purchasing the hotel. Local support for this initiative has been ringing loud and clear; a recent ballot showed overwhelming backing, with an astonishing 98.6% of voters in favour of the buyout. This robust endorsement will be presented to the Scottish Government's community land team as part of the next phase in their attempt to secure ownership.

Iain Mitchell, Chair of the North Queensferry Community Council, expressed optimism about the community's chances of winning their appeal. He indicated that the Trust has identified several “procedural and substantive errors” in the Scottish Government's initial decision. The community's commitment to saving the Albert Hotel, coupled with the recognition of its potential as a tourism and community asset, presents a compelling case for re-evaluation.

The initial rejection has ignited a wider debate about community rights and the role of local input in decision-making processes. As discussions surrounding the legislation on community right to buy gather momentum, it is clear that North Queensferry's fight to reclaim the Albert Hotel will continue to draw attention not only in local circles but also within the corridors of power.

As the struggle unfolds, the narrative of the Albert Hotel is more than just about a building; it exemplifies a community rallying together, determined to secure its heritage against the backdrop of a changing socio-political landscape. The outcome of the ongoing appeal and subsequent efforts to reverse the Scottish Government's decision will be critical in determining both the future of the Albert Hotel and the community that fights to preserve it.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services