Great Yarmouth Borough Council proposes expanding its selective licensing scheme to cover 5,000 privately rented homes across some of England’s most deprived wards, aiming to address health hazards and overcrowding despite concerns over rising rents and landlord backlash.
Great Yarmouth Borough Council is taking steps to expand its selective licensing scheme, a move designed to improve living conditions in approximately 5,000 privately rented homes. This initiative is particularly focused on three wards—Nelson, Cobholm, and Southtown and Central and Northgate—areas identified as among the most deprived in England. The proposed scheme is set to build on a previous initiative launched in 2019, which targeted solely the Nelson ward and reportedly generated almost £95,000 in fines for non-compliant landlords within its initial three years.
Under this new licensing proposal, which is expected to last for five years, the council aims to better combat health hazards, overcrowding, and issues related to inadequate heating and insulation in rental properties. Alongside enhanced property inspections, the council will impose a £784 licensing fee for landlords operating within the targeted zones. It is noteworthy that the council has indicated this fee will not be used for profit but rather to fund the regulatory framework of the scheme.
Paul Wells, the cabinet member for environment and licensing at Great Yarmouth Borough Council, emphasised the council's commitment to addressing substandard accommodation. "Most landlords are good ones and want to provide good-quality homes, but sadly not all are," he said, highlighting the unacceptable reality for many residents living in poor conditions. Wells reassured that the council aims to foster better relationships with landlords and agents to ultimately ensure tenant welfare.
However, the proposed expansion has already drawn criticism from the Eastern Landlords Association. Chairman Paul Cunningham labelled the initiative a "money-grabbing exercise" that would ultimately lead to increased rents as landlords pass on their compliance costs to tenants. Cunningham expressed frustration over the ongoing tensions between local landlords and the council, arguing that the scheme risks alienating those who may already feel unfairly targeted. He stated, "The costs will mean rents increase and more landlords will sell up, exacerbating the existing shortage of rental properties."
The urgency of these measures is underscored by alarming statistics concerning housing conditions in Great Yarmouth. Recent reports reveal that the targeted wards experience significantly higher crime rates, with over half of the 9,809 crimes reported in the borough occurring in these areas. Additionally, a feasibility study has identified a worrying trend of overcrowding within privately rented homes—evidenced by the 112 complaints received by the council over the last three years. A report from the Building Research Establishment notably found that 18% of private rented properties in Great Yarmouth had at least one serious health hazard, compared to the national average of 12%.
Despite the council's efforts, previous initiatives have faced challenges. Residents in the Nelson Ward, for instance, noted that despite the identification of numerous property issues and fines issued to landlords, many still endure poor living conditions. The limited impact of the pilot scheme has raised questions about the effectiveness of the council's approach, with critics arguing for the need for more comprehensive and enforceable measures.
Compounding the issue is a broader crisis in the housing sector across Norfolk. As of late 2023, over 11,800 individuals were on housing waiting lists in the region, with Great Yarmouth alone having more than 800 outstanding applications. The rising demand for affordable housing amid climbing rental prices and living costs further highlights the urgent need for immediate and effective solutions. Recent government reports suggest that while housing in Great Yarmouth is relatively cheaper than in nearby areas, it remains largely unaffordable for many due to stagnant incomes.
As the council prepares to discuss these proposals further, the stakes could not be higher for both tenants and landlords in Great Yarmouth, with the potential for both progress and conflict lying ahead in the pursuit of better housing standards.
Reference Map:
Source: Noah Wire Services
Noah Fact Check Pro
The draft above was created using the information available at the time the story first
emerged. We’ve since applied our fact-checking process to the final narrative, based on the criteria listed
below. The results are intended to help you assess the credibility of the piece and highlight any areas that may
warrant further investigation.
Freshness check
Score:
8
Notes:
The narrative introduces a new initiative by Great Yarmouth Borough Council to expand its selective licensing scheme, aiming to improve living conditions in approximately 5,000 privately rented homes. This expansion builds upon a previous initiative launched in 2019, which targeted solely the Nelson ward and reportedly generated almost £95,000 in fines for non-compliant landlords within its initial three years. The earliest known publication date of the 2019 initiative is January 2020. ([great-yarmouth.gov.uk](https://www.great-yarmouth.gov.uk/article/6247/Great-Yarmouth-Borough-Council-starts-inspections-to-improve-private-rented-housing-under-Selective-Licensing-Scheme?utm_source=openai)) The current report appears to be original, with no evidence of recycled content. The inclusion of updated data and the expansion of the scheme to additional wards suggest a high level of freshness. However, the narrative's reliance on a press release from the council may indicate a higher freshness score but should be flagged for potential bias. ([great-yarmouth.gov.uk](https://www.great-yarmouth.gov.uk/article/6247/Great-Yarmouth-Borough-Council-starts-inspections-to-improve-private-rented-housing-under-Selective-Licensing-Scheme?utm_source=openai))
Quotes check
Score:
9
Notes:
The narrative includes direct quotes from Paul Wells, the cabinet member for environment and licensing at Great Yarmouth Borough Council, and Paul Cunningham, chairman of the Eastern Landlords Association. A search reveals that these quotes have not appeared in earlier material, indicating they are original to this report. The wording of the quotes matches the sources, with no variations found. This suggests a high level of originality in the reporting.
Source reliability
Score:
7
Notes:
The narrative originates from the Eastern Daily Press (EDP), a regional newspaper with a history of investigative journalism. While the EDP is generally considered reputable, it is a single-source narrative, which introduces some uncertainty regarding the comprehensiveness and potential biases of the report. The reliance on a press release from the council may also indicate a higher freshness score but should be flagged for potential bias. ([great-yarmouth.gov.uk](https://www.great-yarmouth.gov.uk/article/6247/Great-Yarmouth-Borough-Council-starts-inspections-to-improve-private-rented-housing-under-Selective-Licensing-Scheme?utm_source=openai))
Plausability check
Score:
8
Notes:
The narrative presents a plausible account of the council's expansion of its selective licensing scheme, supported by direct quotes from relevant stakeholders. The claims are consistent with known issues in the housing sector in Great Yarmouth, such as substandard living conditions and tensions between landlords and the council. The inclusion of specific figures, dates, and quotes adds credibility to the report. However, the reliance on a single source and the potential for bias in the council's press release warrant a cautious approach. ([great-yarmouth.gov.uk](https://www.great-yarmouth.gov.uk/article/6247/Great-Yarmouth-Borough-Council-starts-inspections-to-improve-private-rented-housing-under-Selective-Licensing-Scheme?utm_source=openai))
Overall assessment
Verdict (FAIL, OPEN, PASS): OPEN
Confidence (LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH): MEDIUM
Summary:
The narrative introduces a new initiative by Great Yarmouth Borough Council to expand its selective licensing scheme, aiming to improve living conditions in approximately 5,000 privately rented homes. The report includes original quotes and presents plausible claims consistent with known housing issues in the area. However, the reliance on a single source and the potential for bias in the council's press release warrant a cautious approach. Further verification from additional reputable sources is recommended to confirm the accuracy and comprehensiveness of the information presented.
