The beauty industry has once again been shaken up, this time by e.l.f. Beauty's bold acquisition of Hailey Bieber's skincare brand, Rhode, for a staggering $1 billion. The deal, which includes $600 million in cash and $200 million in stock, could see an additional $200 million based on the brand's future performance. This acquisition not only marks a significant milestone for e.l.f., but it also underscores Rhode's meteoric rise since its launch in 2022, carving out a niche in a competitive market.

E.l.f. Beauty has long pursued a strategy centred on disruption, aiming to challenge conventional beauty standards. Founded in 2004, the brand has positioned itself as a cost-effective alternative in the cosmetics landscape, boasting an impressive track record of success. According to Nielsen, e.l.f. is now the top cosmetics brand in the U.S. by unit sales, and it ranks second in dollar share, despite its average product price remaining well below that of competitors. The company intends to maintain its competitive pricing even after a planned price increase in August, where 75% of its products will still retail under $10.

The acquisition of Rhode, however, marks a shift towards the prestige beauty segment. In just three years, Rhode has made a name for itself through innovative products that resonate with consumers, particularly Gen Z. The brand's success can be attributed not only to Bieber's celebrity status but also to Rhode’s emphasis on community engagement and a methodical approach to product development. Notably, the brand has amassed 11 million Instagram followers—an indication of its strong connection with consumers and ability to leverage social media effectively.

Tarang Amin, e.l.f. Chairman and CEO, highlighted the alignment between e.l.f. and Rhode in terms of their disruptive ethos, stating, “rhode further diversifies our portfolio with a fast-growing brand that makes the best of prestige accessible.” Despite the excitement surrounding the deal, some analysts express caution. Drew Fallon, a former CFO, remarked in his Substack newsletter that the short history of Rhode raises questions about its long-term viability, while TD Cowen's Oliver Chen echoed similar sentiments concerning whether Rhode can sustain its momentum beyond the initial celebrity endorsement.

Rhode's rapid ascent has been meteoric, reporting $212 million in net sales over the past year, predominantly through e-commerce and pop-up shops. Following the acquisition, Rhode plans to broaden its retail footprint by launching its product line in Sephora stores across North America and the U.K. later this year, potentially giving it a significant boost in visibility.

As e.l.f. aims to leverage Rhode's innovative offerings—such as the brand's signature "glazed donut skin" concept—they face the challenge of effectively integrating Rhode's premium products into their existing low-cost portfolio. Rhode, which offers items priced from $18 for lip tints to $32 for its signature “glazing milk,” operates at a price point aimed at a different demographic compared to e.l.f.'s traditional offerings. This shift reflects both a strategic expansion and a need to adapt to changing market demands, particularly as e.l.f. grapples with slowed growth and fluctuating sales. E.l.f.’s revenue growth has markedly slowed, with just a 4% rise reported in its latest quarter, which raises the stakes for the success of the Rhode acquisition.

Bieber will remain actively involved with Rhode post-acquisition, serving as the brand's Chief Creative Officer and a strategic advisor to Amin and the e.l.f. team. Her influence, coupled with what has been described as a "disruptive marketing" strategy, may position Rhode well for continued growth in the skincare and hybrid makeup realm.

Ultimately, the e.l.f.-Rhode partnership has the potential to redefine the beauty landscape further, provided that e.l.f. successfully navigates the complexities of merging their business model with Rhode's premium offerings while retaining the brand’s identity. As Dr. Brent Ridge, co-founder of Beekman 1802, optimistically noted, this collaboration brings together a "business powerhouse" with a brand that has adeptly engaged its community. Meanwhile, analysts and industry observers will be watching closely—this acquisition may be a game-changer or a cautionary tale, depending on its execution.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services